MrGibins's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[A tale of a Brain Snail]

audio aside, a good little skit

I don't know, it was actually aight,

[IE7 for a Webdesigner]

clean up the sound

I LOVED the concept, but the audio needs to be clearer

[Blonde in a Bar]

nice..I guess

the general premise of a bad joke was amusing, but not that funny. However, everyone's reactions to her death was pretty good. I also liked the Testa Taxidermy sign I spotted

[Singing Man]

could have been better

your purple outline detracted from the actual animation, it also would have been better if you concluded it more effectively. I would have been more impressed if I hadn't seen Jameslee do it much better a few weeks ago in his 24in24 project

[Mr. John - The Criminal]

the music earned you a 1

if you need music to cover up your lackluster animation you need to try harder. the overlayed sound at the end proved that you animated, realized that the beginning was unbearable and tried to cover it up with music. You can do it, your art isn't THAT bad, it just requires a lot more time for a good finished product

[Jesus..Christmas..Skyrim.]

SKYRIM!!!

it really does seem this way now adays...

also, a nice portrayal of Jesus, seems like a pretty chill guy

[A Very Goremaster Xmas]

about f**king time!

I love goremaster and this was something I've been waiting a while for. I think you spoiled us with the back to back opening releases but I still would like to see more goremaster ASAP!

[Every War in History Ever]

valid point, everything else was bad

of course people will give you bad reviews if they think you are either wrong or bad at making movies.

I personally agree with your point but felt your presentation was terrible.

bad sound quality (can't deny this)
bad dialogue,
bad art (don't give me any B.S. about why you chose to do a lazy uncolored pencil animation, the simple truth is you either lacked the skill or the effort)
bad animation, (yes this is different, you could have managed some better tweens, better perspectives and transitions, but you didn't, instead you took a slo-mo of two people yelling)

if you want props for rehashing one of the oldest concepts in history i.e.: history is written by the winners/war doesn't prove who is right, just who is left then you need to at least add something new, like good art, good narrative, etc.

p.s. if the 'animation isn't supposed to be spectacular' of course I won't give you a spectacular grade. this wasn't even good so I won't even give you a good grade.

[PokeAwesome]

awesome...of course

poor pikachu took a solar beam to the knee, otherwise he'd still out be adventuring. I love the animation style, it is kind of funny that you need to tell your pokemon what to do, and I can imagine trainers being just like these two, hey, we already know ash is.

Cold1000...jeeze, is it possible for you to be any less specific? you think they don't look realistic? I disagree,
you say this never happens in pokemon? what, you not knowing what attacks to use, pokemon actually having opinions on the matter but being unable to choose for themselves or pokemon freaking out when they're hit? The point is the first one does happen and the next two should. try to be more original? be honest have you ever seen ANYTHING REMOTELY LIKE THIS? no. you haven't but maybe thats becuase you're 12.

anyway... still love the art,
voices awesome as usual,
concept is pretty original

but...not your greatest either, sorry to say,

and.........why am I seeing this and not GirlChan?

[Madness Combat 7.5]

loved it, a quick burst of action

nice action sequences as usual, but not perfect

could have used a more direct connection to the main story line

a final battle with a much strong opponent would be nice

in said final battle I would have liked to see some serious teamwork between Sanford and Deimos

longer is better, but not really necessary

would have prefered if the enemies were tougher,